For employers

Recruitment agency vs labour hire vs hiring direct — which is right?

6 min read·6 October 2026

Recruitment agency, labour hire or hiring casual staff yourself? How each option works, what it costs you, and when each one makes sense for your business.

When you need staff, there are three main ways to get them: a recruitment agency, a labour hire company, or hiring directly. They're often confused, but they work very differently.

Recruitment agency

A recruitment agency finds candidates for you, and you employ them directly. The agency usually charges a placement fee once someone starts — often worked out as a percentage of the role's salary for permanent positions. Agencies are most useful for permanent, senior or hard-to-fill roles.

  • You become the employer from day one
  • You pay a one-off fee per placement
  • The agency screens and shortlists candidates

Labour hire

A labour hire company supplies workers who stay employed by the labour hire company. You pay the company an hourly charge, which covers the worker's wages, super, insurance and the company's margin. Labour hire is common in construction, warehousing, manufacturing and events.

  • The labour hire company is the employer — it handles pay, super and insurance
  • You pay a higher hourly cost than paying wages directly
  • You can scale up or down quickly
  • Some agreements charge a fee if you later hire the worker yourself

Labour hire providers must be licensed in Victoria, Queensland, South Australia and the ACT, and businesses that use unlicensed providers in those places can face penalties. Since late 2024, the Fair Work Commission can also make "same job, same pay" orders requiring some labour hire workers to be paid at least what the host's own employees earn under an enterprise agreement.

Hiring directly

You find, employ and pay casual staff yourself. It takes more admin, but there's no agency margin and you choose exactly who works for you.

  • You pay award wages, super and workers' compensation directly
  • Your ongoing cost per hour is lower
  • You build your own pool of reliable casuals over time

Which is right for you?

  • Use a recruitment agency for permanent or specialist roles where you want help with screening.
  • Use labour hire when you need lots of workers at short notice and don't want to be the employer.
  • Hire directly when you hire casual staff regularly and want to control quality and cost.

Building a casual workforce directly

Many businesses use a mix: labour hire for sudden peaks, and their own casual workforce for everyday needs. On CasualHire, you can search casual candidates by suburb and radius, filter by skills, certificates and availability, and contact the people you want directly. Posting jobs is free, there are no placement fees or commissions on wages, and you can start with a 30-day free trial after verifying your ABN.

Ready to find casual work or staff?

CasualHire connects casual workers and employers across Australia using AI-powered matching.